The Electra complex is a psychoanalytic theory describing a young girl’s supposed unconscious attraction to her father, paired with jealousy and rivalry toward her mother, during early childhood. Carl Jung coined the term in 1913 as a female counterpart to Freud’s Oedipus complex, though Freud himself rejected the label.
Key Takeaways
- Jung’s Term: The Electra complex, first proposed by Carl Jung, is the female equivalent of the Oedipus complex.
- Phallic Stage: Like the Oedipal complex, the Electra complex arises during the phallic stage of Freud’s psychosexual development (roughly ages three to six).
- Turning From Mother: During this stage, a female child supposedly pushes away from her mother and becomes jealous of and displays possessive affection toward her father.
- Penis Envy: According to Freud, penis envy drives this shift: a young girl realizes she lacks a penis and turns resentment toward her mother.
- Unresolved Complex: In Freud’s view, the Electra Complex, if left unresolved, results in neurosis and mental illness.
- Little Evidence: The Electra Complex has been criticized by modern psychology and is widely considered an antiquated concept because there is little evidence to support it.
- Key Critiques: Critics have questioned Freud’s methodology in his case studies and argued that penis envy and the Electra Complex were invented as cover-ups for sexual trauma.
- Lasting Influence: Nonetheless, the Electra Complex still holds a place in modern consciousness, cited in everything from case studies of drug use to psychoanalytic literary theory.
History and Overview
The Electra Complex is the female equivalent of the Oedipus Complex, a term in neo-Freudian psychology. It describes a daughter developing love for her father, alongside jealousy of and blame toward her mother for supposedly depriving her of a penis.
Although many textbooks state that the Electra complex is a Freudian term, Freud used the term Oedipus Complex in reference to both boys and girls.
The Electra Complex derives from Greek myth. Electra was the daughter of King Agamemnon and Clytemnestra. When her father was murdered, she persuaded her brother Orestes to help her kill her mother and her mother’s lover, Aegisthus, in revenge.
Carl Jung introduced the term in 1913. Sigmund Freud, however, said in 1920 that he did not find it useful.
In a 1931 paper on female sexuality, Freud went further, arguing that the Electra complex does not really exist. Only in boys, he wrote, do we find this combination of loving one parent while resenting the other as a rival.
How Does the Electra Complex Work?
Carl Jung, who coined the term, described the Electra complex as part of a broader process of family attachment and eventual detachment. He saw this process as largely non-sexual in origin, reaching its true crisis at adolescence rather than early childhood (Jung, 1913).
Freud, however, is credited with the well-known account.
In Freud’s version, a young girl’s intense early bond with her mother turns to jealousy once she discovers she lacks a penis. She then desires what her father’s anatomy symbolizes, and may become possessive of his attention or hostile when she does not get it.
In Freudian theory, an important part of the developmental process is learning to identify with one’s same-sex parent.
Attraction to one’s father
Freudian theory holds that between three and six or seven years of age, a child begins to want to possess and grow closer to the opposite-sex parent.
A boy may push his father away while kissing and hugging his mother. A young girl, similarly, may insist on following her father into the bathroom.
Eventually, according to Freud, the Electra complex dissolves. A number of defense mechanisms play a role.
In the theory of psychosexual development, the primal id is the instinctive part of personality present at birth. It compels a child to possess her father and compete with her mother.
In order to resolve this conflict, the child must repress their urges and desires in conscious memory (Honig, 2000).
Resolution
Freud also suggested that a young girl discovers she has no penis. This discovery, he argued, produces penis envy: resentment toward her mother for her own lack of male anatomy.
Eventually, this resentment gives way to identification. The daughter incorporates many of her mother’s personality characteristics into her ego, the part of the mind responsible for sorting out what is real.
This process also lets the daughter incorporate her mother’s morality into her superego, the part of the mind Freud believed controlled the id’s impulses (Honig, 2000).
In Freud’s view, this dominant superego lets the child accept her gender role, understand her sexuality, and develop a sense of morality.
Lack of resolution
Freud believed some children never fully resolve the complex. In that case, he thought the girl would keep seeking father figures throughout her adult relationships. She might also show a constant need for approval from father figures generally (Khan & Haider, 2015).
That pattern, Freud thought, could shade into neurosis. Neurosis, in his framework, is a class of chronic, distress-based mental disorders.
Freud labeled adults fixated on these stages father-fixated or mother-fixated.
Controversy and Criticism
The Electra Complex has little supporting evidence. Modern psychologists treat it, like the Oedipus complex, as an outdated idea.
Their criticisms mostly overlap, since the Electra Complex is often seen as a simple extension of the Oedipus complex to women. The Oedipus complex itself rests on Freud’s analysis of a phobia in a five-year-old boy: little Hans (Freud, 1909).
Hans was a real child. Freud describes a boy whose freedom to walk and play in the street becomes tangled up with desire and love for his mother (1909).
Critics question both the case’s validity and its status as the only major evidence Freud offered for the Oedipus complex. That is a real weakness, since Hans’s father, himself a pro-Freudian psychoanalyst, conducted most of the analysis himself.
Other researchers disagree with the interpretation entirely. Bowlby (1973), for instance, proposed that Hans’s fear of horses reflected separation anxiety rather than sexual conflict, an early application of attachment theory.
Karen Horney’s dismissal of penis envy and the Electra Complex
One of the earliest critics of Freud’s Electra complex was Karen Horney. She believed that penis envy, the concept underlying the Electra complex, was both inaccurate and demeaning to women.
Instead, Horney traced female psychiatric disturbance to the male-dominated culture that produced Freudian theory. She countered with a concept of her own: womb envy.
Womb envy suggested that men envy women’s ability to bear children (Vanacore, 2020). Horney’s early-20th-century contemporaries, mostly male psychoanalysts, largely dismissed her.
Freud himself criticized Horney directly. He argued that women who rejected penis envy, including his own female colleagues, were in a state of denial.
Horney’s anti-Freudian theories eventually led to her expulsion from the New York Psychoanalytic Society and Institute (Vanacore, 2020).
Criticism by Sigmund Freud
The Electra Complex is not originally a Freudian concept. Freud’s stages of psychosexual development were largely based on his interactions with his male patients. Freud does not make it clear in his writings whether the Oedipus complex extended to women.
Freud, however, denied any true symmetry between the sexes. “It is only in the male child that we find the fateful combination of love for the one parent and simultaneous hatred for the other as a rival” (1931).
Contemporary Research
Modern developmental science has now tested the Electra complex’s core assumptions directly. The results do not support the theory.
Aim: To test whether young children’s gender identity tracks their sex assigned at birth, as the Electra complex requires, or instead tracks the child’s own asserted identity.
Method: Gulgoz and colleagues (2019) studied 317 transgender children aged 3 to 12 alongside 189 cisgender siblings and 316 matched controls, measuring their gender identity and gender-typed preferences.
This is a large sample for a rare population.
Results: Transgender children identified with their current gender, and showed gender-typed preferences, as strongly as cisgender children did with theirs, with all three groups’ patterns essentially indistinguishable.
Conclusion: Early sex assignment and rearing do not always determine how a child later identifies or expresses gender (Gulgoz et al., 2019); where identity and rearing diverge, identity wins.
The theory’s other testable claim has also failed.
Freud predicted that girls form weaker consciences than boys, but Hoffman (1975) found the opposite: where sex differences appeared, girls showed more internalized morality, not less.
Kochanska et al. (2002) later found that toddler girls displayed more guilt-related behavior than boys in laboratory studies of early conscience.
Examples
In the 1960s, psychological LSD experiments
Despite wide discrediting for its lack of evidence, some neo-Freudians still use the Oedipus and Electra Complexes to describe their patients’ experiences.
One example is Athanassio Kafkalides’s 1996 paper on LSD-assisted psychotherapy. Researchers began using LSD as a psychiatric drug in the 1960s, before its use was later criminalized.
Kafkalides believed his patients’ fixations traced back to the mother and a desire to return to the womb. For both patients, he believed, sexuality was a way of approaching this desire as closely as possible (Kafkalides, 1996).
Florance Rush: The Electra Complex as a cover-up for the aftereffects of sexual abuse
The feminist author Florence Rush argued that Freud’s Oedipus Complex, and Jung’s counterpart the Electra Complex, functioned as a cover-up. Both, she said, concealed reports of sexual abuse and incest by patients’ paternal figures (Rush, 1996).
Rush believed Freud initially drew a causal link between sexual abuse and the neurosis of his female patients, who often reported such abuse (Rush, 1996).
His male patients, however, never complained of maternal seduction. Rush argued that Freud therefore treated the abuse reports as female-specific fantasy: the Oedipus complex in women.
Rush believed Freud grew uncomfortable. His own theory implied that sexual abuse of women was extremely widespread.
As a result, Rush says, Freud recast his patients’ stories as imaginary. Women’s accounts of sexual assault became, in his theory, unresolved Oedipal complexes and fantasies of having sex with their fathers. Rush calls this reversal the Freudian cover-up (1996).
The Electra Complex in Literary Analysis
The Electra and Oedipal complexes have also become a fixture of psychoanalytic literary theory. Critics use them to read fictional characters, though usually detached from Freud’s ideas about repression and neurosis.
One example stands out. Muhammad Shoaib (2014) applied the complex to Shakespeare’s Twelfth Night.
He read Viola and Olivia as driven by a desire to possess their brothers, who served as father figures for them. Both, he argued, represent the phallic and post-Oedipal stages of Freud’s psychosexual development.
Their goal was to replace and imitate their mothers.
Each girl first idealized her father figure, then redirected that wish toward emulating her mother by winning an ideal father of her own and having his child.
Writers after Freud have used the term knowingly. Sylvia Plath, for instance, described her poem “Daddy” as spoken by a girl confronting an unresolved Electra complex in the wake of her father’s early death (Plath, 1981).
References
Bjorklund, B. R., & Bee, H. L. (2000). The journey of adulthood (4th ed.). Florida: Pearson.
Bowlby, J. (1973). Attachment and loss: Separation: Anxiety and anger (Vol. 2) . New York: Basic Books.
Erikson, E. H. (1950). Childhood and society. New York: Norton.
Erikson, E. H. (Ed.). (1963). Youth: Change and challenge . New York: Basic books.
Freud, S. (1905). Three essays on the theory of sexuality. Se, 7.
Freud, S. (1909). Analysis of a phobia of a five year old boy. In The Pelican Freud Library (1977), Vol 8, Case Histories 1, pages 169-306
Gulgoz, S., Glazier, J. J., Enright, E. A., Alonso, D. J., Durwood, L. J., Fast, A. A., Lowe, R., Ji, C., Heer, J., Martin, C. L., & Olson, K. R. (2019). Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 116(49), 24480-24485. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1909367116
Hoffman, M. L. (1975). Sex differences in moral internalization and values. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 32(4), 720.
Honig, A. (2000). Psychosexual development in infants and young children. Young Children, 55 (5), 70-77.
Horney, K., & Horney. (1924). On the genesis of the castration complex in women (pp. 37-54).
Jung, C., & Kerenyi, C. (1963). Science of mythology. In R. F. C. Hull (Ed. & Trans.), Essays on the myth of
the divine child and the mysteries of Eleusis. New York: Harper & Row.
Kafkalides, A. (1996). Intra-uterine security: The cause of the Oedipus and Electra complexes in two cases treated with LSD25. International Journal of Prenatal and Perinatal Psychology and Medicine, 8, 427-432.
Khan, M., & Haider, K. (2015, November). Girl’s First Love; Their Fathers: Freudian Theory Electra complex. In Research Journal of Language, Literature and Humanities, International Science Congress Association [Internet] (Vol. 2, No. 11, pp. 1-4).
Kochanska, G., Gross, J. N., Lin, M.-H., & Nichols, K. E. (2002). Guilt in young children: Development, determinants, and relations with a broader system of standards. Child Development, 73(2), 461-482. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8624.00418
Malinowski, B. (1929). An ethnographic account of courtship, marriage, and family life among the natives of the Trobriand Islands, British New Guinea. New York: Eugenics Pub. Co. The Sexual Life of Savages in North-Western Melanesia.
Plath, S. (1981). The collected poems (T. Hughes, Ed.). Harper & Row.
Rush, F. (1996). The Freudian coverup. Feminism & Psychology, 6 (2), 260-276.
Scott, J. (2005). Electra after Freud: Myth and culture. Cornell University Press.
Shoaib, M. (2014). Electra Complex in Shakespeare’s Twelfth Night. Lapis Lazuli-An. International Literary Journal, 1-8.
Thompson, C. (1943). “Penis envy” in women. Psychiatry, 6(2), 123-125.
