I have a serious problem with unreasonable truths. They're not actually
true, just things that people accept without question. Most of the time because someone in authority declared them so. I had a disjointed chat on twitter about authors not being allowed to read fanfiction. I'll agree that it's on some lever reasonable not to read fanfic of your own published work. But quitting fanfiction altogether because you're... what? Suddenly a different person after you get published? Why? Because of legal issues? Everything worth reading has already been written. Putting your own twist to it is the trick. That leaves being taken less seriously by other "real" authors. Which is a laughable reason to stop doing something you like. Writers aren't an exclusive group of awesome people. They're people, and some of them are really awesome, and some of them are assholes, and most of them are regular people that can be both. And they're not worth it.
My point being, if authors have to steal ideas, they can do it from published literature just as easily as they can from fic. Both cases make them jackasses. It's not in any way good reasoning to quit fic (reading and writing) on some presumed publishing policy.
It bugs me because it's only problematic because people make it a problem. And that occurs in every day life, all the time, about everything. Not that I'll ever write something and publish it and be faced with the problem. But I doubt I'll ever stop doing fan work of some kind. As I've been out of fandom life for a while I wasn't sure if I'd be signing up for
go_exchange this year. But it felt
wrong not to do it. It's not like I've quit reading fic, or lost the urge to create. It's just in the background with all that's been going on. (It's weird, I only know about five people in the exchange this year. I used to have at least a vague idea of everyone back in the day. I feel old. :) But it just makes me think harder about the above.)
And I can't shake the feeling that this belief has a lot to do with the old argument about the validity of fanfiction. I thought we were over that, no? :)
It's all based on my rebellion streak, I guess. Every time someone tells me I'm not supposed to do something I have to ask why the fuck not.